Sunday, 29 April 2012

Dividends or Capital Gains


There is always an abundant deal of pressure on corporations to provide satisfactory rewards to their shareholders. Dividend policy could be seen as part of the increased emphasis on “value-based management”. This is fundamentally a managerial method to corporate strategy that puts the main focus on maximising shareholder wealth. A reaction to this drift, you will increasingly see a company’s annual report and accounts making some clear reference to the aim of maximising shareholder wealth (Boakes, 2011).

A key feature of most corporations’ challenges to maximise the wealth of their shareholders is the regular payment of income to them in the form of dividends. This subject plays a vital role in almost all features of corporate finance.

Gordon (1959) produced modelling price on a corporation’s dividends “capital gains” and its potential growth. However, Modigliani and Miller (1961) argued that dividend policy is irrelevant, because as long as the corporation are realising the returns projected by the market, it does not matter whether that return comes back to the shareholder as dividends now or reinvested. Also, they pointed out that the shareholders could create their own dividends by selling the stock when the cash is needed.

On the other hand, Modigliani and Miller (1961) proposed unrealistic assumptions during developing their model, such as, brokerage costs and taxes did not exist. The reason behind these assumptions is to simplify their analysis.

Furthermore, Gordon (1959) stated that a dividend-in-the-hand is worth more than the present value of a future dividend. On other words, the risk premium on the dividend yield is higher than on the growth rate.


In conclusion, a question would be raised, whether shareholders would prefer dividends or capital gains?

     

Sunday, 1 April 2012

Capital Structure…


Capital structure in corporate finance means long-term finance that a corporate needs to have in order to support a new project, also to maintain growth. Capital structure contains ordinary shares, debt issues, preference shares and retained earnings.





In addition, in corporate finance corporates must choose and balance between equity and debt finance. The difference between these two types of finance is that debt finance has a high risk because the company must make finance commitments to the investors in these securities. If they cannot meet their obligations to pay interest or the principal, they risk being forced into liquidation. However, in equity finance the company don’t make any promise to investors. They know that they will be well rewarded in good years, but they must also accept any losses in income or capital in the bad years.

In the “UK investors dig in over pre-emption rights” article by Kate Burgess, she highlighted the question of whether the pre-emption rights had a detrimental effect on the UK corporations’ ability to fund new investments. Paul Myners, the ex-chairman of Marks and Spenscer has answered the question saying: “the rights were a ‘cornerstone of a company law’ that shouldn’t be removed” and “pre-emption was an important safeguard for shareholders although they needed to be more flexible about waving their rights on occasions”.

Therefore, if the rights issue took away, the cost of company finance would actually rise. As a result, there’s no danger that companies would be able to dilute the value of existing shareholding by issuing additional share capital to new investors…  

Sunday, 25 March 2012

Socially responsible investing


Socially responsible investing is generally ignored by investors who probably still have some deep rooted suspicion that companies that go all soft and protect the environment will be less profitable than those that focus on profit at all costs.

Socially responsible investing is an investment process that integrates social, environmental and ethical considerations into investment decision making. Moreover, it frequently referred to as ethical investments or sustainable investments – interchangeable and/or overlapping (Renneborg et al., 2008).

According to the EUROSIF, SRI is a generic term covering ethical investments, responsible investments, sustainable investments, and any other investment process that combines investors’ financial objectives with their concerns about environment, social and governance (ESG) issues.

Although we might be concerned about the environment, we are more worried about the returns from our company portfolio. However, looking at BP's share price turns the entire argument. Because of the share price that we should be worrying about whether the company we are invested in is following environmentally ethical approaches?

                                          

Companies that act in a responsible way are not damaging the environment will not face unexpected and expensive responsibilities such as cleaning up the Gulf of Mexico.

fisher-french (2009) interviewed Malcolm Gray, portfolio manager at Investec Asset Management in charge of sustainable investments who claimed that a corporation that is responsible is possibly to build investment portfolio over time compared to an irresponsible corporation that runs the risk of taxes and charges to recoup costs. Also, he argued that a time will come where water and air pollution costs will have to be reflected in the costs of production, probably through taxes or legislation. He pointed out that the time is so close: 

“That time is now very close. After the oil disaster in the US you can bet your bottom dollar that there will be a demand for oil companies to pay an environmental tax towards a fund for future oil spills in much the same way that the US and UK are considering taxing banks to fund future bail-outs”.

Gray also stated that corporations who were not making strategies to become more energy efficient would face enormous future costs when energy prices gone up.

We already have seen the price rises that Eskom will be passing on to businesses. A corporation that is focusing on dropping its energy demand is not doing it for an environment factor; it is doing it to survive in the market.

                                            


Socially responsible investing is not something companies do to include in their portfolio to assuage their morality or to show how environmentally friendly they are; it could demonstrate be the investment that delivers their best performance.

Sunday, 18 March 2012

Credit Crunch: why did it impact on Northern Rock specially?

9th of August 2007 was the day the world changed! on that day, the European Central Bank and the US federal Reserve added £45 bn into jetty finance market. However, it was not enough to prevent banks from funding the market.

Northern Rock bank was performing very well since its stock market flotation in 1997. However, after August 2007, credit crunch changed everything. The main focus in the banking sector was on Northern Rock because they had an aggressive business strategy unlike other banks that funds from their savers. Also, Northern Rock increased its finance largely from the financial market.   

(FT, 2007) pointed out that almost 25% of Northern Rock's balance sheet is funded by retail deposits, with the rest coming from various sources of wholesale funding. During the beginning of credit crunches Northern Rock ran out of cash and it was heading into a financial melt-down. As a result, customers queued from outside all their branches to remove their deposits.


The bank adopted a unique operation which is combining with the Financial Service Authority and the Treasury in an attempt to reassure investors and to stop any further causalities amongst the UK banking industry.

In September 2007, the government announced that it agreed to guarantee all deposit held at Northern Rock. Therefore, the run on the bank and the queues outside their branches gradually disappeared.

On the other hand, Bank of England and the government were worried that other banks might adopt Northern Rock strategy because they had some support from them. Bank of England and the government did not have any choice at that time but to help Northern Rock.       





source: http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2011/dec/01/credit-crunch-pinpointed-august-2007    

Sunday, 11 March 2012

Mergers and Acquisitions



Mergers and acquisitions (M&A) play a very important role in corporate finance. For instance, they help to assure that managements of an organisation act in the best financial interest of their shareholders by maximising the company’s share price. If the share price starts to fall, they know that they risk another company coming and making a takeover bid for the business which will almost certainly see the managers lose their well-paid jobs. In addition, M&A activity enables companies to grow their business by being able to exploit opportunities for external growth.

The case of Lakshmi Mittal, the owner of Mittal Steel, who lunched a bid of €18.6 bn for the Luxembourg-based steel maker Arcelor on the 26 January 2006. Lakshmi argued that the deal made sound commercial sense and it would benefit all the stakeholders of Arcelor including various European governments. This tactic was designed to assure the French government, which was mainly hostile to the proposed bid. The main concern was that any takeover would result in server plant closure and job cuts in a country where about 25% of Arcelor’s employees were located. The Financial times argued that there was a particulars aggressive reaction from France’s Finance Minister. The CEO of Arcelor, Guy Dolle pointed out that there is no industrial logic behind combining the two businesses together.   


In 2006, Arcelor used more common approaches to fight off the takeover bid. They announced that they would increase the 2005 dividend and distribute a future £3.4 bn to shareholders. Moreover, they announced that they would transfer the shares that they owned in California firm, Dofasco, to a foundation which would make it much harder for Mittal Steel to sell this business if it succeeded in buying Arcelor.
The European regulators which had investigated that proposed takeover gave the green light in June 2006. Therefore, Mittal Steel was able to takeover Arcelor, though they ended up paying a significantly higher price. This created the world’s largest steelmaker. Also, the process of integrating the companies proved to be fairly trouble free.       

I believe that M&A is beneficial for any company because it reduces the number of competitors in the market and captures additional economic scales of the market. As a result, this will keep the company growth with the merger of the competitive advantages of both firms. 

Sunday, 4 March 2012

Foreign direct investment…



“FDI is the purchase or establishment of income-generating assets in a foreign country that entails the control of the operation or organisation” (FT, 2012).
                                            

FDI is the net inflows of investment to obtain a lasting management interest -10 % or more of voting stock- in an enterprise operating in an economy other than that of the investor. It is the total of equity capital, reinvestment of earnings, other long-term capital, and short-term capital as shown in the balance of payments.

FDI is not only a transfer of ownership as it usually comprises the transfer of factors corresponding to capital, including management, technology and organisational skills (FT, 2012).

Strategically FDI comes in three forms:

1)      Horizontal FDI:
 The company acquires the same activities abroad as at home.
 E.g.:  Toyota assembling cars in both Japan and the UK.

2)      Vertical FDI:
 Different steps of activities are added together abroad.
·         Forward vertical FDI is where the FDI takes the firm nearer to the market.
E.g.: Toyota obtaining a car distributorship in USA.
·         Backward Vertical FDI is where international combination moves back towards raw materials.
 E.g.: Toyota getting a tyre manufacturer or a rubber plantation.

3)      Conglomerate FDI:
This type involves both horizontal and vertical FDI.
E.g.: the Hanson Trust of the UK, Mitsubishi of Japan or ITT of the United States.

FDI can also take the form of Greenfield entry or takeover.

·         Greenfield entry implies assembling all the features from scratch as Honda did in the UK.
·         Foreign takeover indicates the acquisition of an existing foreign company such as Tata’s acquisition of Jaguar Land Rover illustrates.

Foreign takeover is often known as the term “mergers and acquisitions”. However, internationally, mergers are vanishingly small, accounting for less than 1 % of all foreign acquisitions.

In conclusion, although FDI has a beneficial impact on developing countries, it has potential risks as it can be reversed through financial transactions; it can also be extreme owing to adverse selection and fire sales. FDI benefits can be limited by the power of leverage; and a high share of FDI in a country's total capital inflows might imitate its institutions' weakness rather than their strength. 

Friday, 24 February 2012

Foreign Exchange Risks..


International Trade motivates the need for foreign currency transactions. The interdependence of countries and the dramatic trend of globalisation mean a growth in transactions with an international aspect. However, these transactions might cause various risks.

                                                      

There are three types of risk for firms which operate in an international market place: economic risk, translation risk and transaction risk. These foreign exchange rate risks are going to be analysed using an example which is: how the UK economy is being affected by the advent of $2 pound.

The first type of currency risk is economic risk. Arnold (2008) defines it as “the Forex movement cause a decline in economic value because of loss of competition strength”. According to the $2 pound example, the economic risk was caused by raising the pound and making the UK products and services highly expensive in the dollar-based market. Therefore, consumers would search for cheaper alternative products in USA stores. This would lead the UK companies to lose their market share companies based in foreign countries due to the “$2 to the pound USA consumers” shifting to cheaper merchandises.  

It has been noticed that some big companies such as Arm Holding PLC, have responded to the economic risk exchange rate risk by keeping their prices as competitive as possible. On the other hand some companies such as CSR, Bluetooth technology group have responded by hedging- buying derivatives off banks that offset the impact of pound’s raise against the dollar. Hedging might minimise some of the economic risks. However, it is very expensive.
                                           

The second type of foreign exchange rate risk is translation risk. “It arises because financial data denominated in one currency then expressed in terms of another are affected of exchange rate movements” (Arnold, 2008). In other words, companies that supply the US markets through local operation will note that their dollar revenue and cost move together. However, when their dollar profit converted back to pound, the company will take the fluctuation hit.

The final type of currency risk is transaction risk. “The risk that already entered into, or for which the firm is likely to have a commitment in a foreign currency, will have a variable value” (Ibid). This type of risk applies to the biggest UK companies such as HSBC and BP that report their financial account in dollars. There is a direct influence on the pound value of dividends broadcasted in dollar terms. The increase in the value of the sterling against the dollar decreases the value of the dividends received in terms of the local currency. 

                                   

Sources: 
Lecture 5 slides,
Arnold, G. (2008) Corporate Financial Management, Chapter 25., 
Financial Times. 

Sunday, 19 February 2012

Greek government launches new bond issue… Athens prepares 50-year bond issue worth € 500 m- €1 bn.


The international bond markets are a progressively important area in terms of financial market activity (Bokas, 2011). Governments, companies and large organizations, such as banks, are issuing many new bonds every single day.

For the purpose of this blog, I am going to discuss the process of a government aiming to issue a long term securities. In addition, the relationship between a country credit rating and the expected yield on the new bond issue.

In 2007, Greek government was planning to lunch 50-year bond worth € 500 m- €1 bn. This decision was declared by Greek’s finance minister, Petros Doukas. The new issue was timed to impose the strong liquidity in finance market. Greater liquidity in finance market advises that there would be plenty of demand for a new large bond issue.


In the circumstances of the European government bond market, Greece stands out as the market with top level of yields amongst the Eurozone economies. Moody’s, a rating agency, rated Greece’s credit risk at a single A with the outlook recently upgraded from stable to positive.

However, Greece recently is in a worse position now than Britain was 20 years ago due to its unclear and clouded future. Nevertheless rereleasing the Greek Drachma at least offers the prospect of eventual growth because remaining in the euro guarantees a generation of poverty and emigration.


Sunday, 12 February 2012


Market Efficiency.. Facebook serves notice on $5bn IPO

 

Efficient market hypothesis theory (EMH) implies that it is hardly possible to "defeat the market” due to the stock market efficiency causes existing share prices to always incorporate and reflect all relevant information. According to the EMH, stock always trade at its fair value on stock exchanges, making it impossible for investors to either purchase undervalued stock or sell stock for inflated prices. By definition, it should be impossible to beat the overall market through expert stock selection or market timing.

The efficient market hypothesis (EMH) rests on three assumptions: (i) economically rational behaviour by market participants (utility maximization behaviour), (ii) homogeneous expectations of participants in the marketplace and (iii) price movements based on the instantaneous transfer of information by arbitrageurs (Sappideen, 2008). In this blog I will be focusing on the price movement efficiency.  

Recently, Facebook launched the process for its highly anticipated stock market debut, filing papers for a $5bn initial public offering that will turn key shareholders into billionaires, most notably Mark Zuckerberg, the 27-year-old chief executive and co-founder.


For 2011, Facebook achieved $3.7bn in revenues, an 88% higher than the year before. Net income increased 65% in the past year to $1bn, up from $606m in 2010 however; it’s lower than analysts had estimated.

Facebook showed strong growth in its core advertising business, which accounts for 83% of revenues. Payment transaction fees from Zynga, the social gaming company built on the Facebook platform, accounts for 12%. The remainder comes from transaction fees for sales in other games and digital goods like music and movies. 

Facebook said that it would increase $5bn in the offering, a figure that is possibly to rise before the listing in May, making the social networking group’s lunching the largest in the internet industry since Google.

So, should we be so excited about Facebook’s IPO?

According to Warren Buffett who descends from the Benjamin Graham school of value investing said:

“I am convinced that there is much inefficiency in the market… When the price of a stock can be influenced by a “herd” on Wall Street with prices set at the margin by the most emotional person, or the greediest person, or the most depressed person, it is hard to argue that the market always prices rationally. In fact, market prices are frequently nonsensical. There seems to be some perverse human characteristic that likes to make easy things difficult. The academic world, if anything, has actually backed away from the teaching of value investing over the last 30 years. It's likely to continue that way. Ships will sail around the world but the Flat Earth Society will flourish.”



I believe that EMH is highly debatable and often doubtful. Many Investors argue it is pointless to search for undervalued stocks or to try to predict trends in the market through either fundamental or technical analysis.



Sunday, 5 February 2012

RBS

Issues affecting stakeholders of a company.
Stakeholders can be defined as people or organizations that are concerned about, affected by, have a vested interest in, or are involved in some way with the issue at hand. (business dictionary, 2012)
What do the stakeholders know, feel, want, believe, and value in relation to the problem or issue?
What are the threats, risks, costs, and benefits for the stakeholders?
What are stakeholders’ main concerns about the issues? What are the differences in the stakeholders’ concerns about issues? What are the areas of common ground and benefits for various stakeholder groups?
What roles do stakeholders play and what types of involvement do stakeholders want to have in the initiative?

Since the banking crisis British taxpayers and the British government in effect have become the majority stakeholders in the main British banking institutions including RBS and the
The royal bank of Scotland, in particular, had received a huge cash injection from the British government using British tax payer’s money, thus the British public becoming the main stakeholders in this bank.

Through the media the British public i.e. the main stakeholders are being kept informed of any issues that would or could affect the taxpayer’s stake in the bank.
One of the main issues that would concern the British public is the huge bonuses that are paid out to executives at the bank.  Recently the RBS chief executive received almost one million pound worth of shares in bonuses, after much public anger he declined the bonus payment. Immense political pressure was put on senior executives by the British public to forego huge annual bonuses.

Through the media, the British electorate (public) have voiced their anger at these disproportionate annual bonuses resulting in pressure on the government which, in turn, has led to the prime minister, no less to ask the board to act ‘responsibly’.
Other actions requested and voiced by the stakeholders are to tax these huge annual bonuses for example, or to give workers also stakeholders in effect, the right to a say in how much top executives bosses receive in bonuses.  Now that the public is the main stakeholder in the bank they are also demanding a debate of sort to discuss issues surrounding this very controversial area. (The Guardian, 2012)